Why eat meat?

topic posted Wed, April 6, 2005 - 9:11 AM by  Unsubscribed
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Those who claim to care about the well-being of human beings and the preservation of our environment should become vegetarians for that reason alone. They would thereby increase the amount of grain available to feed people elsewhere, reduce pollution, save water and energy, and cease contributing to the clearing of forests.

When nonvegetarians say that “human problems come first” I cannot help wondering what exactly it is that they are doing for human beings that compels them to continue to support the wasteful, ruthless exploitation of farm animals.

Vegetarian diets offer a number of nutritional benefits, including lower levels of saturated fat, cholesterol, and animal protein as well as higher levels of carbohydrates, fiber, magnesium, potassium, folate, and antioxidants such as Vitamins C and E and phytochemicals. Vegetarians have been reported to have lower body mass indices than nonvegetarians, as well as lower rates of death from ischemic heart disease; vegetarians also show lower blood cholesterol levels; lower blood pressure; and lower rates of hypertension, type 2 diabetes, and prostate and colon cancer.

Wheat grass contains 98 out of the 102 earth elements.

Wheat grass is a complete food.

The nutritional content of 15 lbs of fresh Wheat grass is equivalent to 350 lbs of the choicest vegetables.

The vitality derived from Wheatgrass is remarkable. One teaspoon contains as much nutritional value as more than two pounds of fresh green vegetables in vitamin, mineral and amino acid content.

It is a complete protein containing about 20 amino acids (the building blocks of protein) and about 30 enzymes, which are incredibly important for correct digestion and other bodily processes.

On an empty stomach, Wheatgrass is assimilated into the blood in about twenty minutes and the vitality lasts throughout the day.

So why eat meat?

Wheatgrass is a complete protein and provides the following amino acids:
Absensic -- anti-cancer agent
Alanine -- blood builder
Arginine -- seminal fluid
Aspartic -- acid-energy
Histidine -- hearing and nerve function
Isoleucine -- growth in infants
Leucine -- energy and nerve stimulation
Lysine -- anti-aging
Methionine -- Kidney and liver cleanser
Phenylanine -- thyroid function
Proline -- glutamic acid absorption
Serine -- brain stimulation
Threonine -- digestion and assimilation
Tryptophan -- skin and hair growth
Valine -- brain/muscle coordination

BLOOD BUILDER:

Chlorophyll (as in Wheatgrass ) normalizes high blood pressure by dilating the blood pathways throughout the body and stimulates healthy blood tissue-cell growth. Chlorophyll has the ability to break down poisonous carbon dioxide and release free oxygen. Wheatgrass stimulates metabolism and enzyme systems and the abundance of alkaline minerals helps reduce over- acidity in the blood.

BODY CLEANSING:

Wheatgrass has a long tradition as a cleaner of blood, organs and gastro-intestinal tract. It contains saponin, a detergent factor that can help drain the lymphatic system, carrying away many toxins from the body cells. When an imbalance or injury exists, for example, sore tendons or joints or degenerative diseases, there is a natural buildup of mucous in the lymph particular to that area. This mucous is encapsulated, helping to insure the proper flow of lymphatic fluid. Wheatgrass helps to break down the mucous, allows it to drain and thus relieves pressure and aids healing.

ALLERGIES AND SENSITIVITIES:

Wheatgrass is different to wheat, as one is a green vegetable, the other a grain. The green vegetable grass contains no gluten and is therefore no more allergic than spinach or lettuce. In fact it contains anti-allergic factors. Since allergies are immune responses to toxic irritants, detoxification is crucial to any allergy treatment problem.

We are not in an ice age anymore so why eat meat?
posted by:
Unsubscribed
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Why eat meat?

    Wed, April 6, 2005 - 9:34 AM
    Why? Habit, availability, laziness...

    I have thought many times about becoming vegiterian, however, my husband adamantly refuses. Does anyone else have a significant other who eats meat, but they do not? How do you deal? It would basically be cooking two meals every night. Ugh!
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Mon, April 18, 2005 - 12:51 PM
      My husband eats meat, and I gave it up in 1994. He has to cook it himself, 'cause I can touch the stuff. About the furthest I'll go is thowing something frozen in the oven. I have to say, b/c he has to cook it himself, there isn't much meat-eating going on. Fine by me. ;]
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Sun, April 24, 2005 - 7:36 AM
      I am a single Dad of three young men ( now 18, 22 & 25 )

      I have been a vegetarian for years and when my sons were young, I cooked only vegetarian meals for them. When they reached the age of about 16 or so, or expressed an interest in eating some meat, I cooked small amounts of meat for them along with discussion and education concerning the dangers of meat.

      I cannot cook Beef as the smell absolutely nauseates me as well as the fact that I believe that the beef is badly contaminated with hormones, antibiotics and the BSE prions.

      They still eat small amounts of meat at home and whatever they choose to away from home. This has worked well for me as I love to cook and don't mind cooking an additional dish or two.

      Two of my sons are living away from home and still eat pretty much the same way at their own homes.
      Geoff.
  • Re: Why eat meat?

    Wed, April 6, 2005 - 2:39 PM
    Because if your blood type is "O" - as is the case for 50% of Americans - then a vegetarian lifestyle would not be healthy for you.

    It works for Indians, because they are mostly type A or B blood, which is helpful in an environment with a lot of blood-born illnesses, such as typhoid and malaria. Here in America, type O works quite well, except that you need meat.

    It started as a status symbol - because it's so expensive to raise meat, only the wealthy could eat meat more than a few times a year. Then it became cheap but retained its high-society status. We're living on that inertia, which is why Americans eat more meat than is necessary or even healthy.

    If all meat-eaters in America and Europe reduced their meat (and beer) intake by 50%, then our farming practices would become sustainable and we'd have enough left over for many of the world's starving.

    Eating meat is a very natural thing for many animals to do, including humans. The problem isn't that we eat meat, it's that we eat too much of it.
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Wed, April 6, 2005 - 3:33 PM
      Yeah, sorry for the flippant response earlier. Couldn't resist.

      I was raised with meals built around meat and accented with veggies; these days we mostly to do the opposite, with a lot of whole grains.

      I am happy for all the info on wheatgrass.
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Wed, April 6, 2005 - 4:41 PM
        so this wheatgrass info is undisputed then ?
        • Re: Why eat meat?

          Wed, April 6, 2005 - 5:00 PM
          Seems a bit suspicious to me and more than a little far-fetched.

          This particular essay is all over the place on the internet, with no real statement as to whom the author is. My guess is Anne Wigmore.
        • Wheatgrass

          Wed, April 6, 2005 - 5:10 PM
          I don't know about undisputed, but it does seem to have a lot of really nice properties. I spent a summer drinking 1-3 shots of wheatgrass a day, and I did feel really good as a result.

          I'm a fan of it, but I know that that doesn't mean that *everything* they say about it is true. Then again, it might be.
          • Re: Wheatgrass

            Wed, April 6, 2005 - 5:15 PM
            it is pretty expensive , well i guess the only places i have seen it are in really trendy expensive health stores and supermarkets in the snooty areas of town.

            i do like the taste of meat. but i think from my experience my health was not hurt by eliminating it or cutting it out of my diet all together .

            it is difficult to be a strict vegitarian when your friends and family are not entirely comprized of vegitarians ..

            i guess moderation is what i tend to practice.
            • Unsu...
               

              Re: Wheatgrass

              Thu, April 7, 2005 - 8:54 PM
              Yes thats true... the trendy. Its sad to wheatgrass being sold in health stores all bottled up too at 20$ a jar. There is NO live enzymes at all in that . Just fibre.

              Grass only cost about 3 dollars to grow an entire tray...which will give you at least 10 shot on the first growth and about 6 more on the second. You can also take cuttings from your grass and put it in a mason jar filled with water and it will absorb any impurities within the water and add its own beauitufl energy to it which tastes like orgon/spring.

              Grass is a complete protien and a complete food. Ask any cow and look at its muscles. :-)
              Grass contains "live" enzymes and amino acids, which many people vegetarian and non-vegatarian alike are gravely lacking in there diet.

              Optimum health come when the insides (blood) of your body and colon are cleansed enough so that you can FULLY absorb your food. When you kill cook or heat your food you are killing off valuable nutrients. When we are clean inside our body we can eat an orange and recives all 11 nutrients avalable to us. But when we are too poisoned with all this dying, decaying fecal matter that has been lining our intestines and colon wall for years, we maybe only absorb a couple.

              So many of us only clean the "outside surface" of their bodies but never the inside. It is our furosious appetites for food (especially the dead, dying, broiled, & burned) that enslave us. Trillions of dollars going to the hospitals and pharmecutical depos, made off of us the dying, from eating death.

              Someone sent this article/link to me. It adds to what my own Grandfather told me...

              www.maliburaw.com/Native_Ve...rianism_1.htm
    • Unsu...
       

      Some FOOD for THOUGHT... :-)

      Wed, April 6, 2005 - 11:35 PM
      In the old world (which my grandfather taught me about) Indians NEVER ate meat unless they had too. All animals wre highly respected. Their diet was mainly herbs. berries and what they grew. Women who were carrying child were not allowed to eat meat at all. (In our native tribe) Not until the ice age came...

      If we observe Carnivores (tiger, lion, wolf etc), we will see that they are provided with strong curved fangs (canine teeth) and claws which are used as hooks or knives, adapted to tightly grasp, bite and kill their prey. Their molars are perfect to grind raw meat; but these same creatures could not grasp a flying insect in the air, or pick a fruit from a tree, or feed themselves with green grass, for they would be unable to cut or chew it conveniently. Their natural physical conditions do not allow them. They lack the appropriate skills for that.

      Schoen, says in his study on the scientific fundamentals of vegetarianism: "The molars in Carnivores have different sharp ends which work like those of scissors; whereas in Frugivores, they are longer and wider and are only used for smashing (grinding) their food just like a mill works--quite different to ferocious animals." He also stated in one of his works: "The molars of Frugivores, lack sharp ends and therefore do not serve that purpose of mincing meat, whereas Omnivores like bears (and others) are provided with both kinds of molars--those with sharp ends, and those with flat ends. They also have fangs (like ferocious animals) without which they could not grasp their prey. Their incisors (cutting teeth) are similar to those of the Frugivore family. Therefore, with regard to their teeth, it is apparent--as demonstrated--that man belongs to the latter, by nature."

      The Cecum and the Appendix are more developed in Herbivores than in Carnivores. The Appendix in Herbivores (procesus verniformis) is used to collect/accumulate vegetable substances which are difficult to digest, like roughage/hard fibres. In humans, it becomes very small when they grow into adults but it is relatively big in children. According to the well-known biogenic theorem, our ancestors fed themselves with vegetables but eventually the habit of eating meat was apprehended.

      No meat-eating animals perspire. Carnivores do not transpire by their skins, but Herbivores do. If humans have transpiration, they must belong to the latter category by natural principle. That is how trophology/trophonomy (trofologia), shows the inner nature of man.

      According to "estamatología"--the science of the senses/the science of sensorial connection to the environment/the science of the sensorial organs/the study of the senses--we should feel attracted to the smell of blood and live flesh, if we were meant to devour other animals. The sight of dead raw meat should appeal to us and entice our appetite if we actually were meat-eaters, and when feeling hunger pangs, we should run after our prey, catch and kill it, devouring its flesh with pleasure. Whose mouth waters in front of a stinking foul-smelling pig? Can we obtain any flavour from its bloody flesh? But we learnt how to transform taste by using fire and spices. Only then does the flesh become edible. We perverted our senses and degenerated our race through disease caused by wrong diet. Only children whose instincts are purer, resist being given meat which they find hard to chew. They also find it difficult to break up the muscular fibres properly. This is because we lack the proper natural tools for this. Their sensitive awareness is healthier for so are their bodies. Parents force them to eat meat in order to have the so-called balanced diet --completely unaware of the harm inflicted on their healthy little bodies. On the contrary, the sight and scent of fresh ripe fruit pleases our senses. Their tempting colours seduce our appetite. It may be a clue to our original diet, that of our ancestors.

      That is why it is possible to spend an entire life living just on vegetables and fruit, as many people do. On the contrary, no one can stand a single week (not even 5 days) on just meat, without the aid of a piece of bread, or chips, or some other vegetable food that enables better ingestion (and digestion). However, we do not need the help of meat to ease the digestion of vegetables. Why does the body crave for 'something else' when given just meat; why do we need to mix meat with some roughage in order to allow a quicker evacuation? That is because meat contains certain (poisonous) substances like creatine, leaukomaine, xanthine, sarcina, uric acid and some more which are highly toxic, for our nature--but not for that of Carnivores, for which these substances are necessary, in order to keep them healthy.

      Omnivorous means 'eating everything, devouring all kinds of food'. That is, indeed, the description of 'modern' man, the precarious species we have become nowadays. Medical science tries to demonstrate that since the dawn of their origins, humans have been Omnivorous by natural principle. I would dare to say that we became Omnivorous by accident, or better, by degeneration rather than by original design. That is a common mistake: to think that just because we were brought up in an 'Omnivorous' family, it must have always been like this for our ancestors. Maybe the families of our ancestors taught each other to lead healthier lifestyles, sticking to the most possible natural diets because they knew it would enable them to avoid disease. It is well known that strong toxins contained in meats such as uric acid, trigger arthritis and similar illnesses related to articulations/joints.

      Omnivorous animals, like bears, never mix different foods in the same meal, in the way that men do--just to satisfy their greed. Doing that would be a terribly bad combination resulting in heavy digestion, overloading digestive and eliminating organs, which are suddenly given too much difficult work. How to deal with so many different substances is tough work--for each substance needs different enzymes and gastric juices which cannot be held at the same time, for they are incompatible, and produce a clash of acids, with the consequential/resulting pain, gases and other disturbances or troubles like stomach upsets, intestinal discomfort and headaches. What tells bears which foods to eat in order to feel healthy? Instinct does. They know by natural wisdom what to do. They always eat different foods in separate meals; they choose purely raw meat if they get some prey--without mixing it with vegetable food--or else just vegetables and nothing else. They have, as stated before, two kinds of molars: one kind with sharp ends for tearing meat, and the other kind--flat ones--for crushing small fruits, roots, branches and to smash any vegetable food. Man is only provided with just the last kind. No animal needs artificial devices to make their food edible, even less to get it. But we need weapons to hunt, and knives and stoves, because our 'claws' and 'teeth' are not strong enough nor appropriate/suitable for the work. If we were meat-eaters, we would not need to soften the flesh of animals in stews in order to destroy the strong muscular fibres, or mix it with vegetables (thanks to vegetables we do not die of intoxification from the meat).

      Naturalists believe that eating meat is a horrible attempt against nature and our health for we were not designed for it. Our wrong diet is the main cause of our illnesses. According to a microbian test made by Dr Kellogg (cereal producer) from the States (USA), it was found that every cm3 of the tested meats had the following quantity of harmful bacteria (poisonous microbes) producing strong uric acid in the blood.

      On the contrary, he found that in analysing several fruits and vegetables, no trace of harmful bacteria could be seen, but instead, enzymes and citric acid were present, useful for the preservation of the organism and protection of the immune system from disease, thanks to their quality of microbiocide.



      "We now know that man inhabited warm areas, allowing the favourable conditions for a fruit regimen, which according to the Anatomic laws, is his natural diet." - Charles Darwin

      "I am a stronger follower of Veganism by principle, not just because of moral and aesthetic reasons. I truly believe in a Vegetarian lifestyle and I have my faith and hopes in a change of human destiny, thanks to the physical effects and benefits of a healthier diet and its influence on the character of the people. It will bring about some benefit and improvement to human society." - Albert Einstein

      "If someone seriously wants to live a real life, his first decision should be not to kill any animal for its meat." - Tolstoy

      "Those who really want to restrain their violent passions, will do better by starting with their palates." - Ghandi


      May all beings open to love themselves, others and all creatures great and small.... this is a great link to share with your children.

      www.themeatrix.com/

      peace
      • Re: Some FOOD for THOUGHT... :-)

        Thu, April 7, 2005 - 12:09 AM
        Interesting ideas, but not convincing for me.

        I became a vegetarian because my body was sick of all the meat I was putting in it. I was a vegetarian for three years. I stopped because my body was screaming for meat. Today, I feel a healthy balance between the two.

        It is entirely possible that man's omnivorous nature developed later in our evolution. But it developed. It is here now. Denying it, harkening back to a "better" day ignores the reality of today. Today, many humans (not all, but many) need both animal and plant matter to live at optimal health.

        As for people not liking raw food, some people also get green in the gills when they hear about first cousins marrying and having children. Many cultures still do this, and there is nothing genetically problematic with the practice, yet through acculturation we become sickened by the practice. Perhaps the tribes that cooked their meat survived better because they killed off all the diseases and parasites within, and then those tribes' descendants inhereted an acculturated distaste for raw meat.

        There are parts of the world where meat is the main staple, even by members of the "old world". In Alaska, the vast majority of what native peoples eat is animal flesh, and they like it.

        I agree that meat eating is out of control in our culture, but being a fundamentalist about it doesn't solve the problem.
      • Concerning Bear Food Habits and Native People

        Tue, April 12, 2005 - 12:17 AM
        Hello. I am a grizzly bear biologist. Bears are highly opportunistic omivores whose survival is entirely based upon feeding upon a wide variety of plant and animal foods. I have logged over 200 direct observation hours with grizzly bears in the wild and can verify that bears do indeed mix different food types in a single feeding session if different food types are available. However, their feeding habits are usually keyed in with what is abundant at the time. In early spring, there is almost no animal flesh available so they concentrate on eating grasses and herbaceous plant species as the snow melts. Later in summer, when the salmon are in profusion, they will focus their feeding on fish but certainly alternate between animal flesh and berries, at a single feeding location.

        As far as humans go, I would say that our whole morphology and physiology is geared toward...gulp...an omnivorous diet. Our transporation system is much more aligned with say for example, an impala, because we were made to run after impalas. You should check out Henrich's work on why humans run. Out on the open plaines where we all descended from that was our ecological niche...running down prey. Which isn't to say that is all our ancestors did but being tender carnivores, as Paul Shepard described us, has been a part of our evolutionary history for a very long time.

        I would also like to point out that native tribes of the high arctic could not have survived without engaging in the respectful killing of prey animals. In such places in the far reaches of North America there simply isn't enough plant foods to sustain them through the winter and so caribou, seal, and fish have always been integral to their survival. Vegetarianism simply would not exist in such environments.

        I do appreciate your passion and knowledge on this subject. It is clear that you feel very strongly and in a world where so many people have become dull and apathetic it is good to see that some still have a fire burning strong within. But coming from over a decade of veganism myself to the tender carnivore that I am now, it is possible to lead a very healthy and respectful life as a carnivore. Perhaps this would be better discussed as a new thread?
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Thu, April 7, 2005 - 4:45 AM
      I don't buy the blood-type argument and think it's completely bogus.

      It seems as though it was made up by people who want to continue eating meat as those are the only ones I hear using it to support their habit. I've never heard a vegetarian use the argument.
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Fri, April 8, 2005 - 12:10 PM
        I completely agree that it is a reactionary argument - Vegetarians insist that vegetarianism is more healthy for all human beings. Blood-typing is the counter-argument.

        Also, it seems to answer the question of why some people thrive on a veg diet, and others get quite sick when on the same diet.

        So, if the blood-type argument is bogus, what is your explanation for the wasting away that some people experience while on a veg diet? And have you done any research to back up your explanation?
        • Re: Why eat meat?

          Fri, April 8, 2005 - 2:14 PM
          This whole topic should have been kept to a more appropriate forum in the first place.

          Staunch Vegetarianism is more of a religion and crutch for people desperate to make a difference and can't think of anything better.

          Once you get past the point of making the choice to cut out or down on meat for yourself and start to preach then it becomes nothing more than another cult.
          • Re: Why eat meat?

            Fri, April 8, 2005 - 2:28 PM
            i think we are all aware it is a sensitive subject

            and this tribe is comprized of quite a few passionate people with strong points of view.

            occasionally it is a good idea to remember that and just agree to disagree.

            personally i like to see strong arguments bump up against each other and see sparks fly .

            it is how we are able to determine what holds water .

            as long as the arguments don't become personal, and devolve into name calling and immature discourse it can be very interesting.
        • Re: Why eat meat?

          Mon, April 11, 2005 - 9:49 AM
          Nathan,

          I do not personally know one person who has 'wasted away' on a vegetarian diet. I have met many people and even entire families that are lifelong vegetarians who are doing great. My sister and best friends have raised their kids (7 and 4) completely veggie and they are the healthiest and smartest kids I've ever seen.

          There are many more people (some of whom I know personally) who have gotten sick while eating a flesh-centered diet and have developed heart disease and degenerative diseases. This in fact happens to most people. My 'research' is my own personal experience.

          You'll always find 'some' of anything, it's what happens 'most' that counts most.
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Mon, April 18, 2005 - 12:47 PM
        Actually, I have heard this argument before, about how different blood types depend on different foods. And how meat is more important for some blood types than others. I was thankful to learn that I was one of the tblood types tha a meatless diet works for. (After over a decade without meat, I couldn't make myself eat it if wanted to.) Now, wether or not it is true...who knows
  • Re: Why eat meat?

    Wed, April 6, 2005 - 4:56 PM
    Meat tastes nice.
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Wed, April 6, 2005 - 5:57 PM
      Ha! Yes a grilled steak does taste nice. I've eaten less meat as I've gotten older, largely because of laziness (nuked frozen vegetables with soy protein are painfully easy to prepare) also because of less constipation when I eat lots of vegetables and no meat. These days I eat hardly any meat. I like chicken salad though, and I'm not above a burger or steak from time to time. Oh and if someone gives me deer meat, I'll sure chunk it, freeze it, crockpot with BBQ sauce it and enjoy :D

      As implied by an earlier post in this thread, moderation is the ticket.
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Wed, April 6, 2005 - 11:00 PM

        I just finished writing an essay on this topic. My paper's specific to vegetarianism as a fulfillment of the Buddhist Precept of non-violence, but there are some general points I found interesting. Here's a segment:

        --------
        Gary Snyder argues that, in some cases, a vegetarian diet is impossible and even harmful, when considered from a modern global perspective. Snyder is, first and foremost, concerned with developing an effective Buddhist practice for the modern era, which he feels must begin with “simple concrete acts” and that, for many, “mindfulness in diet is a starting point” (Four Changes 41). For Snyder, however, this mindfulness does not necessarily imply that one must become vegetarian in order to honour the principle of non-violence.

        To begin with, he does not see vegetarians as automatically exempt from doing harm – an extension on the limitations of human knowledge and the inevitability of doing damage, discussed in the last section. Snyder asserts, “any kind of gathering or gardening calls for compassion, purity, and respect on all sides: as much mindfulness is asked of the vegetarian as is of the hunter” (Indra’s Net 127).

        Moreover, he feels that when approaching issues of diet and its relationship to non-violence, one should be careful not to “sentimentalize” the issue, as “a key transaction in natural systems is energy exchange, which includes the food chains and the food webs, and this means that many living beings live by eating other beings. . . . We are all guests at the feast, and we are also the meal” (Village Council 76-7).

        In other words, from a larger perspective, all beings are eaten at some point, and so an honest practitioner should be mindful of this, and not deceive him or herself into believing that, simply by practicing vegetarianism, he or she has overcome this basic fact of existence.

        Further, he feels that “the simple distinction ‘vegetarian/non-vegetarian’ is too simple,” and explains his view of the relationship between vegetarianism and non-violence:
        "I do, in fact, accept that principle, as an idea, a challenge, and a goal, appropriate to time and place. To choose not to eat meat is a primary extension of the First Precept, ahimsa, non-harming . . . But this is the saha-world of dukkha, tragic with suffering, and people live in poverty and necessity, animals and plants live mutually on each other. (Indra’s Net 128)

        Essentially, Snyder feels that when people are able to live on only grains and vegetables it is commendable, but that “There are many people for whom this is not a viable option,” such as “the people of the Arctic . . . but also those of the grasslands and deserts, those of the seashore, those of the mountains, [who] have always historically relied on much non-plant food” (Indra’s Net 128).

        -----------

        (for the record, I am a practicing vegetarian)
        • Re: Why eat meat?

          Thu, April 7, 2005 - 12:12 AM
          I agree with this 100%, and this is very much the foundation upon which my other posts rest.

          Thank you for sharing.
          • Re: Why eat meat?

            Thu, April 7, 2005 - 1:12 AM
            Why is it not ok "moralistically" to kill an animal, yet ok to kill a plant?
            Just because we can identify with the life force of an animal, so easy to say "meat is murder", etc, there is a life force in plant life. So killing a plant could be viewed as immoral, and we all should go eat calculated nutritionally accurate synthetic proteins, vitamins, pills, etc?
            As to people being turned off by the hunt. Eh? What? There are many cultures, practices, and rituals, involving hunting. Even today. Some people object to it probably due to their upbringing, or their own moral reflection.
            • Re: Why eat meat?

              Thu, April 7, 2005 - 7:44 AM
              If we believe the argument that 'plants are people too', being vegetarian still causes less harm.

              One kills many more plants by cycling them through animals to get meat than one would if the plants were consumed directly.
              • Re: Why eat meat?

                Thu, February 8, 2007 - 8:56 AM
                By your argument we should kill and eat all the animals which eat plants because they are mass-murderers. Oooh kill the whales too, they eat so many billions of tiny little life forms every day!

                Silly, silly, silly....
            • bryan,

              morally, you mean, havent heard of 'moralistically', lol...

              do you feel anything when you see an animal slaughtered?
              now, when a farmer's reaping a field of corn, does that make you feel horror and disgust?

              if you truly feel there is no difference between ending an animals life, and reaping a plant from that earth (that can grow back), then i have nothing more to say.


              • Animals grow back, too.
                • no, an animal does not 'grow back'. :| do you live on another planet?

                  if you pluck an apple from a tree, the tree survives--if we did not eat apples, they would fall to the ground and rot.

                  when you murder an animal, it is dead, and you have prevented that animal from living out its life breathing, eating, mating, etc.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Another planet

                    Sat, April 9, 2005 - 5:20 PM
                    Sure, the tree survives when you pluck the fruit, but most forms of agriculture (particularly grains) kill the entire plant in the process of harvesting. Some are kept for their seeds to produce the next generation. The process of farming meat is similar.
                    • Re: Another planet

                      Sat, April 9, 2005 - 7:59 PM
                      the idea of suicidal strains of GM crops and how that issue plays into the bigger picture needs to be considered also.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
                    If animals had the same percentage of small parts of them "plucked" (in anology to the apple off the tree), then I believe the injured part does heal. If you outright harvest wheat, it's dead too, it's not growing back. But if you just grab it's seeds for consumption, then yes it lives. But I guess if you only eat the seed of an animal, then it doesn't die either.
                    So maybe you just want to drink animal semen or eat eggs?

                    Earlier... my point about killing a plant vs killing an animal, was to ask:
                    if we can synthetically make the proper nutrients required, is that "better" than killing anything - animal or plant?
                    I would guess most people (veg's or omni's) would prefer to not just eat synth-food? Yes? No?
                    • I wrote this on another tribe and am posting it here>

                      <<you know, vegitarianism has actually been proven to be unhealthy for certain people depending on their blood type. Different areas of the world have produced populations of people with prodominate blood types depending on food available in that area. In the US the prodominate blood type is O, since the prodominate population is from Europe historically. If your blood type is O, being vegitarian can indeed lead to difficiancies no matter how well you regulate your ballance of nutrients. Being an O, I know that when I don't get enough meat protien, I feel extremely weak and irritable. I have tryed a vegitarian lifesyle and failed misserably. I was later enlightened by a nutritionist about the blood type phenomena. I don't know which type is best suited for it but I recommend everyone look it up for their own sake. I don't have a reference though. >>

                      This is not to say that I am against vegitarianism or am "pro meat", I am giving you this to make poeple aware. I do use a low meat diet, usually only one serving of meat per day or every other day. But, like I said above, a meat free diet doesn't work well for me.
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: Why eat meat?

      Fri, April 22, 2005 - 9:26 AM

      Hi just thought I'd reply to the "but it taste nice arguement"....

      Thos of you who believe that taste is a valid argument may like to know that if this is true for animals then it is, as is argued by canibals, true for human flesh. Some excellent and very convincing arguments for not eating meat were made by Henry Salt (1880's to 1920's). Arguments he made in his book the case for vegetarianism. Ghandi said after reading this book whilst in London that after reading Salt's work he became "a vegetarian by choice" (as opposed to birth). Salts main argument is that just because something tastes nice is no justification for eating it.. the argument of a cannibal.

      What Salt argues is that meat is not necessary in order to provide nourishment (true, although some dispute it but the fact is a large proportion of the world survives and is healthy on a vegetarian diet) and that the animal does not wish to be eaten. As human beings we are able to identify with that wish and as humanitarian beings grant it. In essence we have the cognative ability to realise the animals desire not to die at our hands. Such abilities are arguable what distinguish as as human beings. Salts arguments are timeless, they have stood for over 100 years and I would recomend reading the anthology of his work (sorry I don't have a reference but I had a remainder copy so pretty sure it's available via amason, abe etc).

      A further argument is proposed in the book Devouring a hungry planet, the meat business (edited by Tansy.. I think). This argues that the cost of meat production in terms of input reduces the productivity of land, the factor is near 20:1. With a population of over 6 billion and much of that population switching to high meat diets the presure on land to produce grows... In fact each meat eater requires 20 times the land to produce his/her food than a vegetarian... If we all maintain high meat diets how do we propose to produce it? We have seen over the last 40 years a decline in habitat and biodiversity as a consequence of land being bought into agricultural production largely to produce fodder to feed domestic animals which in turn feed the meat market.

      Meat may taste good, it may be nutritious but it is not essential. If, as its increasing production does, threaten the survival of the planets diversity we should consider whether or not it is a luxury we can afford.

      another issue that is rarely discused is the globalisation of meat.... huge production takes place in the far east, much of which is destined for western markets. These markets have grown as much out of legislative changes in the west as they have out of direct demand. In Europe now the battery farming of chickens is destined to be phased out by 2009 (it will be deemed cruel after but not before that date???). The demand for this cheap meat however is not being addressed and so the production is switching to the far east (just like manufacturing and service industries) where wages are lower and legislation in welfare is lacking. One of the likeli and very real consequences of this "national scale" meat production is to provide extreme conditions in which diseases (i.e. Asian bird flu) can become established and mutate... there has been a lot of this in the news recently.

      At every corner one turns one finds another reason why we should address our desire for meat...
      In summary the three main reasons are:

      1) it is a purely human ability to identify with the wants and to grant such wants of our fellow creatures. They don't want to be eaten so as a human one can grant that wish whereas an animal is likely to be intellectually unable to make this realisation.
      2)meat is expensive in land and energy consumption and with the huge global population we must reconsider our requirement for food against the desire to maintain the Earths bio-diversity.

      3) intensive crop production does not harbour virus or other diseases which can directly threaten our own survival whereas intensive meat production can and in recent times has.

      But one can continue to argue that it tastes nice and so eat it... personally I don't anymore but I will confess that I miss it... Meat does taste nice but that is (IMHO) and Salt's before no arguement.

      regards,

      greenman-23



      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Thu, February 8, 2007 - 9:10 AM
        Sure, and you could apply the same concious control of desire to your craving for sugar, cofee, tea, cocaine, speed, gasoline, cosmetics, eloctronic goods, etc and acheive a much larger impact. The focus on meat is an infintile emotional hang up, and it obscures the majority remainder of excesses that all of us, including if not especially Vegans and vegetarians participate in on a daily basis.

        It's similar to the ridiculous token exchange program for environmental polluters, using a single poster-child action to claim immunity from ethical wrongdoing. That makes it all about self interest and not about reducing harm.
  • Re: Why eat meat?

    Thu, April 7, 2005 - 8:58 AM
    I have a friend who is allergic to nearly everything - wheat and soy are only two things. She has to eat meat to survive. She tried to be a vegetarian but couldn't find enough protien sources that didn't cause horrific side effects and further aggravate her fibro myalga. To be as healthy as she can and make it through a day, she must consume meat protien.
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: Why eat meat?

      Thu, April 7, 2005 - 8:59 PM
      ALLERGIES AND SENSITIVITIES:

      Wheatgrass is different to wheat, as one is a green vegetable, the other a grain. The green vegetable grass contains no gluten and is therefore no more allergic than spinach or lettuce. In fact it contains anti-allergic factors. Since allergies are immune responses to toxic irritants, detoxification is crucial to any allergy treatment problem.

      Grass is a complete protien and a complete food. Ask any cow and look at its muscles. :-)
      Grass contains "live" enzymes and amino acids, which many people vegetarian and non-vegatarian alike are gravely lacking in there diet.

      Optimum health come when the insides (blood) of your body and colon are cleansed enough so that you can FULLY absorb your food. When you kill cook or heat your food you are killing off valuable nutrients. When we are clean inside our body we can eat an orange and recives all 11 nutrients avalable to us. But when we are too poisoned with all this dying, decaying fecal matter that has been lining our intestines and colon wall for years, we maybe only absorb a couple.

      So many of us only clean the "outside surface" of their bodies but never the inside. It is our furosious appetites for food (especially the dead, dying, broiled, & burned) that enslave us. Trillions of dollars going to the hospitals and pharmecutical depos, made off of us the dying, from eating death.

      Someone sent this article/link to me. It was refreshing and further adds to what my own Grandfather told me...

      www.maliburaw.com/Native_Ve...rianism_1.htm

      Love & light to you...and all.
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Thu, April 7, 2005 - 10:09 PM
        Q'Yin - the link is dead.

        Does anyone know of any good wheatgrass cleanses / books that discuss wheatgrass cleansing?
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Fri, April 8, 2005 - 5:45 AM
      Laura,

      Your poor friend sounds like a complete mess, health-wise. Usually with Fibro myalgia or Lyme disease, one of the ways back to health is a vegetarian diet. I suppose your friend just needs to do whatever she needs to do. Any idea how she got into the horrible state in the first place or has she always been sickly?
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Fri, April 8, 2005 - 9:30 AM
        She's always been pretty sickly. Since she's actually been able to identify what she's allergic to and avoid those things, she's doing better. Her diet is so restrictive that she basically cooks all her food, never chances to eat out or at anyone's house, and just sticks with what she knows. If she can maintain that diet she has a lot more energy to get on with her life. It's tough.
        • Unsu...
           

          Re: Why eat meat?

          Fri, April 8, 2005 - 10:46 PM
          Thats sad... its hard to be really sick.

          Maybe she might ponder the idea that to cook ALL your food is killing the live enzymes and vutal nutrients her body so needs in order to replenish her cells. Freeing one self from our appetites and addiction: that is the key.

          Even carnovourous animals eat their food raw.

          I will send prayers her way.

          Peace
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: Why eat meat?

    Fri, April 8, 2005 - 10:07 AM
    Okay...so I'm a bit snarky right now... But it bothers me when folks come down on meat eaters... I don't eat a lot of meat, because I think too much can be really bad for you, but I love meat and everyonce in a while indulge. And I think that is okay... I know the whole "If everyone was a vegitarian, we'd end world hunger"... well that's BS, too... Yeah we COULD feed the whole world on a veg diet, but WOULD that really happen. No. Besides, I think it is healthy to eat a bit of meat once in a while... After all we are omniverous creatures, and while we shouldn't rely on meat alone, a purely vegitarian diet is not the answer to deforrestation, world hunger, and the overall peril of the planet.

    Buy free range. Buy organic. Buy consciously.

    Eat healthy. Eat moderately. Eat veggies, grains, fruit, soy, AND meat.

    Okay so basically I'm saying it's cool to be vegitarian/vegan/rawist, whatever, as long as you can respect those of us who chose to continue consuming meat responsibly.

    And oh yeah... Americans as a whole consume WAY TOO MUCH meat... And slaughterhouses are repulsive... And debeaking is animal cruelty... And deforrestation is just plain stupid.

    Okay. I'm done.

    peace

    Jesse
    • Ending world hunger

      Fri, April 8, 2005 - 12:05 PM
      From what I understand, the United States alone throws away more than enough food to feed the world's hungry. It's a matter of distribution, not scarce resources.
      • Re: Ending world hunger

        Fri, April 8, 2005 - 6:32 PM
        that's the truth! the congress just approved $82 billion 2 days ago to fund the war in iraq. think of all the good that could be done if that money was used for humanitarian aid instead of killing the earth and its people.
        • Re: Ending world hunger

          Fri, April 8, 2005 - 7:54 PM
          Humanitarian aid usually only makes the problem worse. Very few such grants ever actually get to the people it is sent to.

          Humanitarian aid is an oxymoron, because in the end it is neither humanitarian or any form of aid.

          I agree with your sentiments though, too bad the governments get in the way and screw it up.
        • Unsu...
           

          Re: Ending world hunger

          Fri, April 8, 2005 - 10:51 PM
          Yes... it is sad. Our Mother Earth is soon going to shake the shit off her back if we don't stop.

          May love rain....
        • Re: $82billion

          Sat, April 9, 2005 - 12:45 AM
          Could that $82billion++ be spent on energy programs and R&D in the US, instead of wasting it (along with thousands of human lives) in a futile effort to secure mideast oil reserves which are going to run dry anyway. How pathetic.
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Sat, April 9, 2005 - 9:38 AM
      I agree 100% Jesse! I am a recent born again chicken eater. I was on a vegetarian diet for about 7 or 8 years and about 2 years or so ago started to get intense cravings for chicken. I denied these cravings and would try to eat more foods with protein (figuring that was why I was having the cravings). About 6 months ago I just gave in to the cravings because I was listening to my body and figured there was something in chicken that my body was missing and I wasn't getting it through the other foods I was eating.

      I dislike when people come down on others for their choices. Yes, I also agree that Americans in general could deal with eating less meat, hell we could deal with eating less period! We are a society of glutenous people...we always want more, more, more! But if someone decides to eat strictly veg or eat meat, that is their choice! If people are trying to eat consciously (free range, organic, locally grown) then that is a huge step in the right direction. If more people did that, regardless of their diet choice, then we might see some changes in the world overall.

      It does no one any good to think they are better than anyone else. That's how we get into the world-wide messes we are in right now!
  • Re: Why eat meat?

    Sat, April 9, 2005 - 9:33 AM
    Wheatgrass is in deed wonderfull stuff,i grow it in a box under one 20watt sparlamp(a lamp that saves electricity)in a cupboard and then juice it(using a hand juicer)
    WARNING---if you have never tried Wheatgrass before,drink it in <small> amounts to begin with,if you drink to much to soon ,the <cleaning> process that it starts can be to much for the stomach,don't forget you flora and fauna.
    Wheatgrass will clean out <toxins>and inpuritys in the blood and will give you the right flora and fauna.
    Enjoy;0)
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Sat, April 9, 2005 - 11:18 AM
      wheatgrass is yummy. lots of people have to hold their noses to drink it, but I think it tastes like sweet green heaven.

      reading all of your posts here, I'm realizing again how strongly people feel one way or the other about meat. I could insert the reasons why I choose to be vegan here, and insist upon how much healthier most (not all) people would feel, bodily and karmicly, how much it is better for the planet and animals, etc.. but I really do believe that your diet is about the most personal thing there is, and it's entirely up to you to decide what it contains or doesn't. no one should go around insisting that everyone else limit themselves to one thing or another, and it doesn't work anyway. you just end up with people who are further turned off to vegetarian/vegan lifestyles.

      I think sometimes us vegetarians and vegans need to give up trying to convert people and just live by example. for example, there are all this speculation about how being veg/vegan is often unhealthy, that one's blood type affects those health levels, etc. based on scientific studies and it's more expensive, not available everywhere and blah blah, and I'm not saying that they're completely unfounded. however, I am a one in a million living examples of how untrue these statements can be. I get sick maybe once a year for a few days. I'm a type O blood, so I eat lots of spinach. I survive on delicious vegan goodness for probably half the cost of a meat and dairy diet.

      why not eat meat? it's common sense. it could also be common sense to go to macdonalds everyday for some people. but it isn't up to me to judge. and I don't think I'm a better person because I'm vegan, altho maybe I'm a healthier one.

      here's a link if'n you're interested: www.notmilk.org

      CELEBRATE FOOD, LOVE AND LIFE

      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Sat, April 9, 2005 - 12:17 PM
        "I think sometimes us vegetarians and vegans need to give up trying to convert people and just live by example."

        Very good point. This was my approach when I was a vegetarian. A lot of people's hackles would rise when they learned that I was a vegetarian (one of my sociology teachers once hit me with a 2-minute tirade about how unpractical my philosophy was, without even knowing my philosophy - only that I was vegetarian), but for me it was a personal choice, not a crusade.

        Besides, if the world could sustain Americans eating 50% less meat, then my not eating meat meant that one other American could eat meat to his/her heart's content. If we're trying to be altruistic here, let's truly be altruistic.
        • Re: Why eat meat?

          Sun, April 10, 2005 - 3:44 PM
          I agree, give up trying to convert people to your beliefs, you are not a religon,every one to his/hers own poison.
          I am an ENYTARIAN.
          ;0)
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Sat, April 9, 2005 - 2:36 PM
      so you can just buy the seeds in any gardening store then ?
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Sun, April 10, 2005 - 5:53 PM
        So, in response to all this babble, I'll retort with some of my own. I was a vegetarian for 3 years, and I was very careful about what and how I ate, but I found myself falling ill often. A doctor friend of mine decided to run some blood tests as he suspected mono. Come to find out their was nothing wrong with me other than my blood levels of protein were extremely deficient! Needless to say, I now eat meat though not excessively, and my health and energy is drastically improved. Oh, and by the way, I am a type-O.....
        • Jim
          Jim
          offline 8

          Re: Why eat meat?

          Sun, April 10, 2005 - 10:22 PM
          that is interesting moetchie. about 6 months into being a vegetarian, i starting having very odd symptoms and i had so many tests run, blood taken, went to many doctors. i was finally told i must have fibro because there is nothing else they can test. blood is normal, etc. i have since started eating fish again and eggs and things have gotten a bit better but my energy levels are down, i have depression issues that i cannot get out of (even with the help of medication) and i have a real tough time concentrating along with some now and again aches and pains everywhere. my therapist wants me to start eating meat again, she thinks that is what did it. i'm not aware of my blood type (i know that is bad). i just wonder if being a vegetarian doesn't work for my body. i may try a detox first to see how that goes. glad to see i'm not the only one with issues.
          • Re: Why eat meat?

            Mon, April 11, 2005 - 10:21 AM
            I think we really fall into dangerous ground when we try to apply blanket philosophies and diets to all physiologies...We are all unique and what works for one may not work for another. I learned this the hard way. Our human bodies have sooo many variations, I think to attain true health we must learn to listen to the messages our bodies send us and respond appropriately, even if it goes against some ideology we are trying to impose upon ourselves. We too are animals and deserve health and respect. I hope you get to the bottom of your ailments soon.
            • Re: Why eat meat?

              Mon, April 11, 2005 - 12:32 PM
              >I think we really fall into dangerous ground when we try to apply blanket philosophies and diets to all physiologes...

              I wholeheartedly agree.
              btw, I am a blood type-O and I've been a vegetarian for five years, a vegan for 6 months. I had my blood tested within the first year and yes, it was low of protein, so I made an effort to eat more green veggies. I've since been extremely healthy, and I don't have to go buy wheatgrass to sustain it. eat veggies yo. especially if you're not a veg. meat may have a jolt of protein, but you'll never get the vitamins, minerals, etc. to keep you healthy living on what most americans do. why do you think we have so many doctors?
              • Unsu...
                 

                Re: Why eat meat?

                Mon, April 11, 2005 - 12:50 PM
                Because we are all connected with Gaia and she knows what we all need to be healthy and strong..
                I agree, each one of us has our own needs.. what works for one may not work for the other. Like all life we are a part of the cycle of death and birth. If we keep our choices alligned with gaia we will contribute to the cycle.. these choices are to each his/her own. Beauty is truly in the eye of the beholder.
              • Re: Why eat meat?

                Mon, April 11, 2005 - 2:42 PM
                emilylime wrote:
                > eat veggies yo.

                While I am a meat eater, I do totally agree with you.
                I find it disappointing when I go to a restaurant, order something, they bring a hunk of meat, fries, and some weak excuse for a vegetable, often honey/sugar coated too.
                I do generally go for a baked or mashed potatoes (fries have too much fat - except steak fries have less, but they're more rare to find), but I do wish there was a good selection of vegetables. Most evenings I'll cook with my meat, some carrots, cauliflower, broccolli and/or peas.

                At a buffet, I have had comments with those I'm with at the small portions I get, so while I do eat meat, I don't go crazy like many people seem to!

                Is it a balance, so to just eat too much meat is one extreme, but I believe just eating vegetables is the other extreme too. I'd guess most people at either end of the unbalanced end of the food they eat will all say they are just fine eating just meat or just vegetables, and can quote how people they know have been wonderful on it for years, and that the other extreme is bad, but I believe it's all about balance and harmony. Really.
                • Re: Why eat meat?

                  Mon, April 11, 2005 - 2:49 PM
                  I totally agree about friggin restaurants! You get this huge piece of meat, huge amount of starch, and a tiny salad. Balance, yeah. This is probably why I always feel sick after I go out to an American restaurant.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: Why eat meat?

                    Mon, April 11, 2005 - 8:23 PM
                    and the good vegitarian or "health food" resaurants realize this and over charge beyond belief.
  • Re: Why eat meat?

    Thu, April 21, 2005 - 6:36 AM
    Humans since as far back as antropologists, storytellers, shamans, and books can look back have been eating meat from other species within our terran family. I say we should respect our fellow terrans by treating them and the earth in a respectful manner. This means no factory farming, no ingesting body and earth polluting "supplements" eat wild when possible i.e fish, eat grass fed (free range) red meats (because your body requires healthful saturated fats from animals for brain and muscle development) No support for industrial plant production. Garden if you can and don't use pesticides or herbicides or any of that nasty crap that kills us all.

    Calling ones self enlightened or conscious while supporting industrial farming methods which are destroying the soil and water we (all creatures) need to survive is horrendously selfish and short-sighted.

    Naturally grains aren't even supposed to be such a large portion of out diet. Imagine a neolithic cereal grain farmer... well that was a challenge to your imagination and I'm sure you got as funny and impractical picture as I did. There was no such thing. Which means that our bodies did not evolve to subsist mainly on ANYTHING which can only be naturally found in an inedible state (this means you can't eat it without complicated processing).

    If you wan't to be a vegitarian for whatever reason I say "good luck" and get tested for nutritional deficiencies several times a year and try to find a way to fix your problems without adding to the damage you are already creating (I do not mean damage caused by your diet because if you are growing your own veggies your not really doing any harm, if you do it correctly). If you live in an apartment or elsewise do not grow your own food try to get it from local growers at a farmers market or CSA. Please do not assume that you are healthy just because you are getting an energy boost from juicing wheat grass. Although wheat grass is a great natural source of many nutrients it is lacking in many things required for a long healthy life.


    Why eat meat? Because ruminants are more efficient at converting plant matter into stored energy.

    If everyone on the planet depended on solely vegetable matter for suvival our topsoil would disapear at an even more frightening speed then it is today. By this I mean we would be nearly the last generation.

    Live, Learn, Change - Namaste


    I would like to appologize if I come off like an ass and slightly off-topic.



    For info on how to garden well without harming:
    store.solarlivingstore.com/howt...ove.html
    • Re: Why eat meat?

      Fri, April 22, 2005 - 6:42 PM
      You said "your body requires healthful saturated fats from animals for brain and muscle development"

      Who says? There are plenty of children that grew up as vegans who had healthy brain and muscle development. It may be more difficult to get one or two certain fatty acids from purely plant sources, but it is not a requirement.

      You said "If you wan't to be a vegitarian for whatever reason I say "good luck" and get tested for nutritional deficiencies several times a year ". This statement makes me believe that you think its a losing proposition to be a vegie and that they are destined to have nutritional problems. Did you realize that India has 6 billion people and 83% of them are vegetarian? You'd think that deficiencies would be rampant throughout Asia if that were the case, would you not? Also, the vast majority of Seventh Day Adventists are vegetarians and many studies have been done on them stating that they are healthier than the average American.

      You said, "ruminants are more efficient at converting plant matter into stored energy". That may be true of grasses, but not grains that most of our livestock is fed. You can feed something like 10 times more people on the grains fed to a cow in its lifetime than would be fed on the meat of that cow- that's NOT more efficient (and yes, I DO realize that you suggested we eat grass fed meats). And just because something is more efficient at converting something into protein, does not mean that we need to EAT it.

      You also said, "If everyone on the planet depended on solely vegetable matter for suvival our topsoil would disapear at an even more frightening speed then it is today. By this I mean we would be nearly the last generation. " What is the source of your information? We are feeding livestock absolutely enormous amounts of grains. If everyone stopped eating meat products, we could use those same fields for grains, fruits and vegetables for people and have LOTS of land left over, plus we could plant the grazing land and have even more land left over. And plants like trees and shrubs that produce fruits and vegetables can develop root systems to prevent erosion and the loss of topsoil.

      While I agree with many of your statements, telling people not to be vegetarians because it will harm their health and destroy the environment is blatently false.

      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Sat, April 23, 2005 - 3:49 AM
        On the issue of fats for brains - There are many sources of these fats but to my knowledge to get them in any quantity from anywhere but meat is highly energy intensive.

        On energy efficiency and grains - Grains are not naturally such a large part of any mammals diet. To digest them we humans must first mill them. Nothing is healthy on foods not adapted to. Growing and harveting grains on a large scale is incredibly damaging to the environment.

        As for vegitarianism - I have no problem with and have tried it myself for about a year. I was lacking is energy and quite irritable, but that is just me. I was not saying that it is bad to be a vegetarian I'm just saying get checked out and really that goes for everyone. If you are starting a new way of eating you should be checked for nutritional deficiencies.

        On adventists - My girlfriend was raised one. I used to think, like you that they are all rather healthy (I have meet some that eat well) but her insights into there general poor eating habits were a shock to me. Her whole family and most of there old church have terrible eating habits. I also read on a doctors site that Adventists have a higher rate of cardiovascular disease then Mormans.

        On top soil - I suggest you read the book "Fatal Harvest" it is the compilation of 20 years of research on farming practices. It compares Industrial Methods to More sustainable techniques and is ful of valuable info and touching pictures.
        My statements about the enviroment are not false. "Industrial Farming" is one of the leading causes of the mass extinction that is occuring right now. I am including all types of factory farming in this statement including meat production. Yes plants and trees can be used to prevent ersion and they are used for this but large scale food producers are never looking out for the health of the earth that is the antithesis of what they do.

        I love your spirit.
      • India's population

        Sat, April 23, 2005 - 1:09 PM
        India has 6 billion inhabitants? Since when did they amount to 100% of the world's population?

        And, if you read my post above, one of the reasons why Indians can be vegetarian is because their blood type makes it easier for them to do so (along with making them more resistant to blood-born illnesses such as malaria). Most Americans have a blood-type that makes it harder for them to be vegetarian (and also more suseptible to blood-born illnesses).

        In any case, we are all individuals with a complex set of needs. To say that any one diet is appropriate for every human body seems, well, a bit myopic to me.
        • Re: India's population

          Tue, April 26, 2005 - 11:40 AM
          Sorry about the inaccuracy of the pop of India. OK, it more like 100 million (www.census.gov/ipc/prod/ib-9701.pdf) But that's still a heck of a lot of vegetarians living just fine- especially as most are lifelong vegetarians. I, too, find the blood type argument to be nonsense. Gabriel Cousens MD in his book "Conscious Eating" delves into this at length. As he is an MD, he took a sampling of the people that he works with who have been raw vegans for a long time. He found that many (including himself) are Type O, the blood type that is not "supposed" to be able to live on a vegetarian diet. He DID state that he found that many of these people (including himself) DO tend to feel better having a slightly higher percentage of protein in their diet than some of the other people that he works with. He found that once one becomes aware of their higher need for protein, that just upping this intake in plant sources was just fine and seems to suit their needs very well.

          Also, commenting on the B-12 issue, Gabriel Cousens also delves into this at length in "Conscious Eating" as well. He states that in the studies that he has done on many long term raw vegans, he found that yes, they tended to have low B-12 levels, BUT that they felt great. So he has hypothesized that possibly vegans just don't need all that high a B-12 levels. He states that his personal level was quite high and that he regularly supplements with a particular algae from Klamath Lake and uses a large amount of sea vegetables, both of which are supposed to have bioavailable B-12.

          If one is intelligent and does research on their diet and above all, if feeling well- then obviously things are going well. EVERYONE, no matter what their diet, should obviously be making changes if they feel bad, look bad and/or have health problems. Vegans who are not feeling well, don't necessarily have to start eating meat to feel better, but there is probably SOMETHING that they are missing and they should try to figure out what that something is.

  • Re: Why eat meat?

    Fri, April 22, 2005 - 4:47 AM
    I have heard that vitamin b12 is only available through animal products. The b12 in spirulina and wheatgrass I heard was not bioavailable, and actually stopped absorbsion of b12 from other sources.

    Could anyone confirm or deny this? I have been vegetarian for many years and if I discover the vegetarian diet is deficient of b12, I'll get tested for b12 levels, and may I maybe get a double hamburger with cheese on the way home, lol.

    I became vegetarian after reading Anthony Robbins book "Awaken The Giant Within" and seeing dozens of baby boomers die of heart disease which is common among meat eaters. Tony Robbins reported on John Robbins' findings, which remain shocking to this day, as detailed in 'Diet For A New America'.

    Meat tastes good! Through mindfully eating meat I have discovered why. But a strong note of warning... meat eaters may want to stop reading here...

    Eating meat seems to taste good because it triggers the animal pleasure of being a predator, and its corresponding hormonal rush. Mindful eating taught me that the actual taste of meat is the metallic tang of blood and the spicy stink of uric acid, with the carcinogenic burnt flavour in the after notes. Yum.

    Immaneul Kant precisely pinpoints the pleasure of eating meat:

    "Is life biased towards pleasure or towards pain? The answer to this can be easily ascertained by contrasting the pleasure of the animal eating its prey to the pain of the animal being eaten alive."

    The "taste" seems to be a predator trance. Blood tastes bad. People who watch humans die find they get accustomed to killing, so it's not much of a step from there to getting pleasure in eating the dead. Gaia seems to enjoy to knock off folk that get their kicks from it, frankly.

    I sometimes eat it when there's no other alternative. It tastes good. I just don't feel quite human after eating it. Once the predator is pinpointed behind the rush of the calories it's not the same.

    PB
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: Why eat meat?

      Sat, April 23, 2005 - 3:56 PM
      you can get vitamins like b12, which typically come from meat, from nutritional yeast. Yeah nutritional yeast! Soo gooood!

      *peaches*

      Jesse
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Sun, April 24, 2005 - 2:25 AM
        Fantastic thanks! I will get some and just pass on the blood test for b12 then.


        Yummm...nutritional yeast. :-)
      • Re: Why eat meat?

        Sun, April 24, 2005 - 5:36 AM
        Hmmm...if we supposedly need meat to get B12, where do you suppose the 'meat' we're eating got *their* B12 from? (rhetorical)

        A nutritional reference I have has the following to say about vitamin B12:

        B-12 Cyanocobalamin (destroyed by heat) - promotes growth. Increases energy. Helps prevent anemia. Forms and regenerates red blood cells. Helps iron function better in the body and helps the placement of vitamin A into body tissues. Essential for the normal functioning of all cells. Maintains a healthy nervous system. Important for healthy bone marrow. Necessary for the metabolism of carbohydrates, fats, and proteins. Helps improve concentration, memory, and balance. Can be produced by the body in the intestines.

        FINEST FOOD SOURCES:

        Alfalfa
        Alfalfa Sprouts
        Beans (sprouted and whole)
        Bee pollen
        Comfrey (herb)
        Dulse
        Garlic
        Ginseng (Korean Siberian)
        Grains (sprouted and whole)
        Kelp
        Lentil Sprouts

        Nutritional Yeast
        Nuts
        Seeds (sprouted and whole)
        Soybeans (sprouted and whole)
        Spirulina
        Sprouts (all kinds)
        Wheatgerm
        Wheatgrass
        White Oak Bark (herb)
        • Unsu...
           

          Re: Why eat meat?

          Sun, April 24, 2005 - 10:48 PM

          B12 in animals is manufactured by the animal.......

          this actually applies to several amino acids.

          in essence arguments about the essentiallity of meat are as frivolous as arguments about the round/flat state of the Earth.... some people regardless of the truth will always choose to believe otherwise....

          I noticed some comments about India further up and felt that as I have been surviving on a basic Indian veggie diet for some 5 months now I am in a position to comment...

          whilst a large number of indians are veggie a fair number are not .. those that are do suffer from nutritional defiencies.. the diet in general lacks fibre... these defiencies however are due purely to lack of understanding about nutrition and not the absence of meat... most of which is mutton (goat) and chicken.... beef is extremely rare here... the cow holding a rather odd position of being sacred however the reasoning behind this should and in my opinion equally applies to all sentient creatures.....

          regards,

          greenman-23
          • Re: Why eat meat?

            Tue, April 26, 2005 - 2:27 AM
            excellent discussion here except one consideration is missiong if not two.

            One is that all factory farmed meat at your supermarket is lacking in vital omega 3's which are integral to digesting the meat. health experts tell you you can supplement this lack with flax seed oil or fish oil but the meat originally came with its own unique digestive aid that a toxic cannabalistic diet leeches out. It causes a mineral imbalance not only in the animal but in those who consume the meat and this leads to prion disease or other wise known as Cretzfelf-Jackob Disease and Variant...otherwise...madcow.

            Understand you do not get the disease by eating one diseased animal or by contact....you get it by not having the proper mineral balance in your own system which you were meant to get by eating food...incl meat.

            So over a period of time of eating supermarket meat without proper supplement which also brewers yeast would provide...(selenium)...you are opening yourself up to possible Alzheimers...which is how it will be diagnosed in american society due to bush laws.

            Please realize that meat can be called 'organic' that is fed dioxioned (mercury contaminated) fish meal as 1/3rd of its diet....as well as feetilizer runnoff and other unmentionables.

            Please also note that it is a complete lie to all that removing the brains and spinal cord etc prevents the disease to humans. A mineral disreuption is throughout the body and pesticideds made from army surplus nerve gas that are absorbed through the skin of the animal also contribute to this off-balance demineralization.

            if you eat meat and fish on a regular basis it is wise to do a detox and to use chorella and other sea vegetables to help remove the heavy metals....it takes a long time to do...years....

            It would be preferable to buy from a local farmer or to buy bison meat from a reputable company.

            As for flavor.

            Be aware that flavor does dazzle the tastebuds....as in excito-toxins...in all your fast and frozen foods. And excito-toxins are a slow death exciting your brain cells to death.

            My second consideration is that in olden times when it was point and shoot or point and spear meat or fish...tha animal had a good life as its nature directed.....

            Some cultures such as the asian look to foods for power besides nourishment...so a vigorious bull provides gusto....

            I think it is cruel and self defeating to cripple all animals and crib them in a stall for human and animal consumption.

            The waste is causing problems.


            Remember one other thing...we dont just eat fiber and vitamins and minerals....these all have electro-magnetic properties....in other words our real nutrition is energy....and also in balance...positive versus negative....

            There is no plant that can come near the positive energy of meat.

            however ..I am a Type A and although meat is supposed to energize those doing mental work...it makes out of me a complete vegetative mess. I get my real energy and light by going vegetarian.
            • Re: Why eat meat?

              Tue, April 26, 2005 - 2:53 AM
              I also just read an article about india..that many children are indeed malnourished more so than ever before due to the sugar cane industry supplanting another indian product called gar....which has a low shelf life but provided tha basic minerals now missing from their diet.

              Spices and herbs...take tumeric for example are extremly high anti-oxidants....green herbs are often more potent and nourishing than vegetables.....

              also unhomogenized..and unpasturized milk is much healthier....the fat in homogenized milk is broken down into such tiny molecules that they bypass the liver and seep out the intestines to gather around the heart muscle which needs saturated fat....however these unprocessed fat molecules then eat out the heart muscle....causing heart thrombosis...heart attack....the muscle being weakened and destroyed.

              There was no heart thrombosis before homogenization.


              Tryptophane is good for depression and promotes meat eating. many insist that high cholesterol prevents their depression and studies agree. Saturated fat is not a problem.....trans fats are.
  • Re: Why eat meat?

    Fri, February 9, 2007 - 2:53 PM
    Each to the other is Manna from Heaven
    and for Humans the choices are vast
    We're explorers, inventors and hunters galore
    devouring everything as we explore
    it's the way we are designed to be
    right or wrong equals negativity

    So three cheers for Butchers,
    hip hip hooray
    to the Huntsmen of Century Twentyone
    for bringing us our daily bun
    If they don't kill our meat
    we'd be trampled under cloven feet
    and overcome with methane
    from a rampant living larder.

Recent topics in "GAIA - the earth is alive"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Lets Discuss Health care Daniel Kaiya 11 February 6, 2010
Multiverse, The Awakening Chad 0 February 5, 2010
Awesome! Daniel Kaiya 4 February 2, 2010
I need help Chelsea 23 January 29, 2010